The Rough and Tumbler test, which entailed filling carry-on suitcases until they weighed 20-25 lbs and tumbling them up to 1,000 times, is among one of the tests done by Consumer Reports. The tests determined which of 12 brand suitcases were the toughest of travelers. The report was quite interesting and you can see the chart to the left of what was found in terms of durability, capacity and convenience.
The bottom line is, Tumi was rated best overall with more room than most brands! Highest in quality and price, the Tumi Alpha 22″ Carry-On costs $595. It was also determined that there are other brands that cost less and are still good quality but didn’t perform as well in every test category. It comes down to your preference and price range as to what bag is perfect for your needs. So don’t overlook the Victorinox NXT, Hartmann Stratum and Briggs & Riley Baseline or any of the other top carry-ons!
by Dana Walsh Director of Marketing & Recruiting · September 16th, 2008 
2 responses so far ↓
Tumi alpha 22 is the absolute best. I have been to over 100 countries, most of them 3rd world, in the last 15 years and my Tumi has made it through without any problems whatsoever.
first class stuff, but pricey………….
I am looking for mid - priced luggage to check in and to carry on. Between $150 to $200 for a 28 inch bag and between $100 and $125 for a carry on bag
The one condition that the luggage must have is four swivel casters
The question I have not been able to get fully answered is should it be made out of a polyester fabric or is it definitely better made out of Nylon?
Any products used in making must of the lower priced bags are plastics and fabrics that are carcinogens?
Thanks in advance for your answers.
Leave a Comment